Coastal Commission votes unanimously to oppose Beachwood settlement bill

posted by Barry Parr on Apr 13, 2008 at 11:19 pm in  Environment   Real Estate   Video
5 comments • Print Share on Mail, Facebook, Twitter…

California Coastal Commission
Click to view the Coastal Commission's discussion of AB1991

The California Coastal Commission voted unanimously at Thursday’s meeting to oppose AB1991 in concept so that commission staff could prepare for hearings next month and be able to present the commission’s opinion of the settlement.

In proposing the resolution, Commissioner Sara Wan said, “This is a very bad settlement agreement and could set terrible precedent. So, I would like this commission to oppose in concept this and to give the staff the ability to deal with it.”

Commissioner Steve Blank seconded the motion, saying, “I think this is a big deal.”

The whole item lasted just three minutes. Click to watch.

Comments

Comment 1 by Kevin J. Lansing  on  Apr 14  at  6:07am  •  All my comments • 

Returning to my earlier analogy (see link) between the Coastal Commission and another public regulatory agency, the Securities and Exchange Commission.

http://coastsider.com/index.php/site/news/stop_sb_1295_defend_coastal_commission/

What if Gene Mullin was a member of U.S. Congress and he proposed a bill that would exempt one well-connected company, let’s call it ENRON, from having to comply with the SEC’s mandatory accounting regulations?

Anybody with an ounce of common sense should recognize that this would be horrible public policy and shouldn’t even be considered.

Same goes for Mullin’s bill to exempt Half Moon Bay (and Keenan) from complying with our state’s mandatory environmental regulations.

Comment 2 by Ken Johnson  on  Apr 14  at  12:25pm  •  All my comments • 

AB 1991 and the Settlement Agreement - Another Nail in the Coffin!

Ken Johnson

Comment 3 by Steven Hyman  on  Apr 14  at  5:16pm  •  All my comments • 

I was wondering which one of the Friends of the Coast would be the first to try and kill the bill.  It won’t be long now till the others add their 2 cents.

It still remains to be seen how this will play out in Sacramento.  Its probably too much to think that common sense will prevail.

As a result,  HMB may be one of the first towns that can have a $23 million Wetlands Theme Park (which includes the $5 million down payment made to the lawyers).  I envision a Disney type ride going through the towering wetlands with an Al Gore Green Amphitheatre extolling their beauty and contribution to stop global warming. And maybe we can have some of the docents dressed as red frogs to help people spot them better.  After all,  they only appear on vacant lots that are about to be built on.

This is truly a very sad situation that hasn’t run its course yet.  Too bad for all of us.

Comment 4 by Carl May  on  Apr 14  at  6:13pm  •  All my comments • 

Common sense would suggest a settlement that did not demand exemptions from a number of applicable laws. Do the city council members of Half Moon Bay imagine they are somehow separate from the rest of the state? As Wan said, it is a terrible precedent. Previous legal erosion of this sort—a lessening of Coastal Act regulations on one property being used to justify the same kind of act-busting activities on other properties—is one of the reasons the Coastal Act has become so feeble.

Comments displaying ignorance of the well-established environmental science involved do nothing to demean the facts and principles of the situation. A property does not have to be in pristine natural condition to have coastal characteristics worthy of protection. If development had not already destroyed roughly 95 percent of California’s coastal wetlands, there might be more of a basis for compromise. But there isn’t. If we, as a society, invested more in understanding the various kinds of wetlands and how to restore them after assaults on their integrity, there might be possibilities for mitigation off-site. But we haven’t.

Politics and the power of money might yet prevail to let the Beachwood settlement happen, but if it needs to get by on the facts on the ground, it’s dead. Only time will tell how Half Moon Bay’s blunder of almost a quarter of a century ago will play out.

Comment 5 by Ken Johnson  on  Apr 15  at  1:24am  •  All my comments • 

Steven,

You wrote, “to try and kill the bill” - that presumes the fantasy that AB 1991
has shown any life since it was introduced on 14 Feb 08. It has not! The Settlement Agreement pulled the life support on 1 April.

The forthcoming California Coastal Commission staff reports may assist the City if / when it goes to court for the Bankruptcy Reorganization Hearing in setting a reduced value on the $18,000,000 settlement amount.

As to your F.O.F., Fear Of Frogs, I can’t help you there - I always liked Kermit the Frog.

Ken Johnson

 

Add a comment

Please Register and Log in to post a comment.

Click here to post your own letter to Coastsider.

Princeton Seafood Co. on board with “Hats Off to Teachers”

Letter by Princeton Seafood Company on Fri, Mar 12 at 04:14 pm • 1 comments; click to add your own

Campaign Offers Educators Hearty Discount

Where would we be without our teachers? They’ve given us the fundamentals – the foundation we need to succeed in today’s society. And now, Princeton Seafood is giving something back. With JointVenture’s “Hats off to Teachers” campaign, the restaurant is offering all teachers 10 percent off any meal daily and a full 20 percent off on our special “Teacher Tuesday.”

To receive a discount, teachers must present the restaurant staff with

Read more...

Sam’s Chowder House Hosts Fundraiser Supporting the Big Wave Project

Letter by David Vespremi on Fri, Mar 12 at 11:25 am • 2 comments; click to add your own

Have a comment?

Twitter @samschowder
 
Mail:

4210 North Cabrillo Highway
Half Moon Bay
CA
94019

Telephone: 650.712.0245
Fax: 650.712.0371

Read more...

Free educational events at New Leaf Community Markets

Letter by Patti_Bond on Thu, Mar 11 at 10:13 am • 0 comments; click to add your own

On Tuesday, March 16 from 6 - 7 pm, New Leaf Produce Director, Mark Mulcahy, will present ” For the Love of Produce: Citrus.” Mark will talk about the difference between various types of citrus, where they come from, how to select them and prepare them, as well as provide suggested pairings and recipes.

On Tuesday, March 23 from 6 - 7:30 pm., Larry Jacobs of Jacobs Farm/Del Cabo and his team will give a talk on Organic Farming in Mexico. They will tell their story about the cooperative they

Read more...

Information Session on Roundabouts

Letter by Len Erickson on Wed, Mar 10 at 12:45 pm • 0 comments; click to add your own

Roundabouts were one of many features discussed in the report from the Traffic and Trails meetings last June and presented to the Midcoast in a public meeting last month.  On Saturday, March 13, there will be an information session on roundabouts open to interested members of the community.  The meeting is sponsored by Midcoast Park Lands and will be at the Granada Sanitary District office in El Granada, at 504 Avenue Alhambra, 3rd Floor.  The meeting time is 10:30am.  There will also be an

Read more...

Earlier letters

...Looking for something even earlier? Try our letter archives.
Get Coastside alerts from Fire Dispatch on Coastsider's Twitter feed...