Should the Coastside be more like Foster City?

Editorial posted by Barry Parr on Jun 02, 2005 at 08:16 pm in
7 comments • Click to email this story

City of Foster City
"While Foster City is something of a triumph -- a beautifully laid out community of attractive homes and condominiums, with parks and lovely lagoons on which boats sail, and miles of bicycle paths -- it is also a reminder of the tragedy that no such community can be created today in many places, including the county in which it is located." -- Thomas Sowell

Apparently, hysterical lefties are the only thing keeping the Coastside from being more like Foster City. That’s the conclusion you’d reach if all you had to go on was a pair of articles by Thomas Sowell linked from the Californians for Property Rights website today.

CPR is operated by Coastsider Terry Gossett, who was active in the unsuccessful struggle to keep the Midpeninsula Open Space District off the Coastside and is now fighting the changes to the Local Coastal Programs in both the city of Half Moon Bay and the unincorporated Midcoast.

Today, the CPR site links and quotes approvingly from two articles by Hoover Institution Senior Fellow Thomas Sowell. Well, the original version of the post quoted approvingly. The current version merely links.

Both of Sowell’s articles are worth reading for their entertainment value. Who can afford it? claims that open space laws are the reason that Bay Area real estate is so expensive. No, really, I swear that’s what Sowell claims. But I’m going to focus on A relic of the recent past, which declares that Foster City is “something of a triumph”:

While Foster City is something of a triumph—a beautifully laid out community of attractive homes and condominiums, with parks and lovely lagoons on which boats sail, and miles of bicycle paths—it is also a reminder of the tragedy that no such community can be created today in many places, including the county in which it is located.

It is not that there is no vacant land left in San Mateo County. On the contrary, more than half the county consists of vacant land on which laws forbid the building of anything. Yet environmentalists there, as elsewhere, conjure up a vision in which the last few patches of greenery are threatened with being paved over.

I’d like to quote the whole thing, which is delightfully entertaining. You should read it for yourself. I recommend it. 

My opinion of Foster City is a matter of record. In a recent column in the Half Moon Bay Review, I said, “If we want a new library, or a new park, or smooth roads we have three alternatives. We can resolve to pay for them ourselves, stop complaining, or move to Foster City, where the roads are well-paved—and so is the coastline.”

Foster City is a wonderful community if you don’t like to leave your car.  They have indeed done a lovely job of paving what Sowell calls a “swamp”. Its parks are magnificent when viewed through your windshield. Its Chevy’s and its Olive Garden are as fine as any in America.  I’ve cycled along the Bay in Foster City and I can attest the fact that the asphalt bike trail that constitutes their coastside is flat as a Republican income tax. I’m sure its lagoons are lovely, but I don’t own a house on any of them, so I’ve never gotten a very good look.

If Thomas Sowell is asking us to decide whether it’s a “tragedy” that there will be no Foster City on the Coastside, I know where I stand—and I think I know where you stand.

Comments

Comment 1 by Alex  on  Jun 03  at  9:52am  •  All my comments • 

I live in Foster City, and I agree that the place is great, But in any case I would accept to lose more of our green forests and wild spaces to create a building in Half moon bay or other place.

This is a none caring opinion that you have there.

We have to take care of our wildlife coastal as we have to take care of our community.

Regards

Alexander Pious

Comment 2 by Chris Dove  on  Jun 03  at  10:24am  •  All my comments • 

This post, Barry, is by far my favorite Coastsider entry.

Having grown up on the Coastside and spent nearly 5 years working in Foster City, I can’t begin to tell you how spot on your summation of Foster City’s soulless approach to urban planning.

Foster City was seemingly designed and built only for the Olive Gardens, Chevy’s, and Visa’s of the world: no weeds, no on-street parking, a few “parks” that have been meticulously manicured, and yes, the paved “shoreline” where, if you’re lucky, you’ll get a nose full of the sewage treatment plant a mile up the road. A true “commuter city,” if there ever was one, where people simply go home at night, close their doors.

That said, I think Mr. Pious missed the point. The Foster City approach to taking “care of our wildlife coastal” was simply to dump some rocks down, slap some asphault on top and call it done. The Foster City approach to taking “care of our community” is to build block after block of cookie-cutter condos and track homes in a bland, Levittown-like setting.

Comment 3 by Elizabeth Tyler  on  Jun 03  at  7:19pm  •  All my comments • 

What does Foster City look like to me?

Looks like what they are today calling “Smart Growth”.

Isn’t that supposed to be a Good Thing?

Comment 4 by Barry Parr  on  Jun 04  at  9:18am  •  All my comments • 

There are some fundamental problems with Foster City. The number-one problem is that it’s built for cars, not people. That’s why moving the middle school from Cunha to Wavecrest is a problem. Traffic flow is a big driver for that decision and it will certain decrease the number of kids walking to school.

FC’s shopping is inhospitable to pedestrians, unlike HMB’s downtown. Foster City is all about strip malls, which is a huge planning blunder rooted in its 1960s origins.

Another issue is that you can’t build community from scratch. Darin Boville wrote a great column for the Review about how the “new urbanists” are trying to recreate the community we have in our coastside towns:

http://hmbreview.com/articles/2005/05/18/news/editorial/story3.txt

Comment 5 by Spencer  on  Jun 04  at  4:18pm  •  All my comments • 

I love the many ‘small town’ aspects of HMB, from ‘Rock the Block’, to the owner operated non-chain stores, to the ability to walk down town and see someone I know. In some dimensions smaller means having less, and in others we have so much more than the ‘Foster Citys’ of the world.

My observation is that people who have lived on the Coast for more than a couple years, and is not in the construction business, are anti-growth. We don’t owe development firms a place to build. We owe the people that live here the right to preserve it.

Spencer Nassar http://deepdarksee.com

Comment 6 by mal.comX  on  Jun 06  at  12:32pm  •  All my comments • 

Spencer Nassar wrote: “My observation is that people who have lived on the Coast for more than a couple years, and is not in the construction business, are anti-growth…”

Unfortunately, there are way too many residents who are simply clueless about how special the Coastside is. These are people who go around complaining because they have to drive over the hill to shop at WalMart or Costco. In addition, there are lots of others who make their living in construction and real estate. So it’s actually a miracle that the Coastside is as well preserved an unspoiled as it is. That is not going to last if the people mentioned above have their way.

Comment 7 by Elizabeth Tyler  on  Jun 06  at  9:18pm  •  All my comments • 

mal.comX wriites:

“These are people who go around complaining because they have to drive over the hill to shop at WalMart or Costco. In addition, there are lots of others who make their living in construction and real estate.”

I’m not trying to start a flamewar here, but saying this is so does not make it so.

How many people outside of your regular group of acquaitances have you actually discussed this with? Or are you just going by something that you “perceive” as true?

Just wondering. It is a rhetorical question that I am asking. No answer needed. Just think about it is all I ask.

Cheers! Audry


Add your own comment

Please Register and Log in to post a comment.

 

Get your story or comment on Coastsider. If you're a member, log in to submit a story. Not a member? Please register to submit a story.
Search Coastside and San Mateo County media.