Wavecrest applies for permit from US Army Corps of Engineers

posted by Barry Parr on Feb 8, 2005 at 05:10 pm in  Real Estate
9 comments • Print Share on Mail, Facebook, Twitter…

Wavecrest’s developers have applied with the US Army Corps of Engineers for a permit to build on their property, which has been found to include wetlands and habitat for the endangered California Red-Legged Frog.

The application for a permit under Section 404 of the Clean Water Act proposes the construction of a couple of California Red-legged Frog breeding ponds within the delineated wetlands on the Wavecrest site. A recreational trail is also proposed.

The Corps has not yet reviewed the application, according to Holly Costa, Regulatory Project Manager with the Corps.

The first step in the process would be a new delineation of wetlands on the property. The last delineation was approved in 1999 and expired after five years. According to Costa, the earliest this could begin would be April.

The process would also require the Corps to consult with the US Fish and Wildlife Service under Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act for potential effects on Red-Legged Frogs and San Francisco Garter Snakes.

A section 404 permit also requires a 401 Water Quality Certification, which is issued by the State Water Quality Control Board, via a Regional Water Quality Control Board; and, for projects such as Wavecrest that fall within the Coastal Zone, California Coastal Commission approval.  Without either of these, the Section 404 authorization is invalid.

CORRECTION: The original version of this story said that Wavecrest’s developers were seeking the Corps’ OK for the mitigation of the development. That’s not correct. They’re seeking the Corps’ OK to build the ponds. A correction with more detail is now online.

Comments

Comment 1 by fennel  on  Feb 8  at  5:35pm  •  All my comments • 

I don’t know how they intend to get around the Bolsa Chica court ruling in Bolsa Chica Land Trust v. Superior Court (1999) 71 Cal. App. 4th 493

from http://www.procopio.com/publications/pdfs/HI_august_2000.pdf

“The court in Bolsa Chica held that development-related impacts on ESHAs cannot be mitigated through off-site restoration —  even when the restoration project promises to create “better” habitat than that in the affected ESHA.  Instead, the ESHA itself must be protected and preserved.”

ESHA = Environmentally Sensitive Habitat Area

Comment 2 by Kathy Switky  on  Feb 8  at  6:13pm  •  All my comments • 

I have two questions: are the proposed ponds to be onsite or offsite?  If they are on Wavecrest property, the Bolsa Chica decision wouldn’t apply.

And second, how do the developers propose that a recreational trail will mitigate for habitat loss?

Comment 3 by Barry Parr  on  Feb 8  at  7:28pm  •  All my comments • 

The breeding ponds will be within the delineated wetlands on the Wavecrest site.

I have been waiting for the answer, and I just got it from the Corps. I’ve updated the story to reflect it.

Comment 4 by fennel  on  Feb 8  at  7:30pm  •  All my comments • 

I don’t see anything in that PDF to indicate onsite somehow escapes the requirement to protect an ESHA.  Do you have a reference?

Comment 5 by Michael La Guardia  on  Feb 8  at  7:32pm  •  All my comments • 

Does anyone know if the Corps permitting process allows for community comment and involvement?

Comment 6 by Barry Parr  on  Feb 8  at  7:39pm  •  All my comments • 

I don’t think we have enough information to say one way or the other.

Comment 7 by Michael La Guardia  on  Feb 8  at  7:46pm  •  All my comments • 

One interesting thing to note is that Wavecrest is proposing to build ponds as mitigation for Red Legged Frog habitat lost, but the area has been designated as habitat for both the frogs and for the San Francisco Garter Snake.  Also, I seem to remember that in the USFWS’s letter about the disking they noted that dry grassland areas near to wetlands were important for snake burrows.  Ponds don’t seem to offer mitigation for snake habitat.

Comment 8 by Barry Parr  on  Feb 10  at  5:22pm  •  All my comments • 

I was told this by Holly Costa of the Corps of Engineers:

To answer Mr. LaGuardia’s question: Yes, the Corps does consider community comments.  All letters should be sent to:

Attn: Regulatory Branch
US Army Corps of Engineers
333 Market Street, 8th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94105

and please reference file number 29405S

Comment 9 by Dot Norris  on  Mar 2  at  8:41am  •  All my comments • 

Will drainage from developed areas will not impact the proposed ‘constructed red-legged habitat’?  No sense in mitigating a polluted pond.

Will this habitat be suitable for the Garter Snake also?

file number: 29405s

 

Add a comment

Please Register and Log in to post a comment.

Click here to post your own letter to Coastsider.

Poetry Night at HMB Library, Fri, Sept 10

Letter by Joe Toschik on Wed, Sep 1 at 07:41 pm • 0 comments; click to add your own

Everyone is invited to a night of poetry at Half Moon Bay Library on Friday, September 10th at 7:00PM.  Join us as we celebrate the participants in our 13th annual Teen Poetry Contest.

Read more...

A ballot measure to increase HMB sales tax?

Letter by Bob Poole on Mon, Aug 30 at 01:43 pm • 4 comments; click to add your own

What insanity is this? Raise the sales tax by 1% and drive even more shoppers over the hill. I think that this will kill Main Street shopping for good. Rather than save Half Moon Bay from bankruptcy, I expect it will create a ghost town. Just my opinion.

Read more...

Pacifica DUI checkpoint

Letter by Tim Payne on Fri, Aug 27 at 10:50 pm • 3 comments; click to add your own

I want to start by saying that I think DUI checkpoints are great. They remove dangerous elements from our roadways. What I didn’t like today was being asked to show my drivers license at one tonight.

Under normal circumstances if I commit an infraction and get pulled over I fully understand why I would have to show my papers to an officer in the course of being ticketed. Tonight I was asked to show my papers just because I was on the road. It irked me. I wanted to know if this was legal and

Read more...

African Hybrid Cat (Savannah) Roaming in Montara

Letter by Margot Lowry on Mon, Aug 23 at 09:14 am • 3 comments; click to add your own

In the past month my housecat has been severely sliced up twice.  I wondered if a bobcat and he now had overlapping territories.  Then yesterday afternoon I found this hybrid cat, (I believe it is a Savannah cat which is a hybrid between a Serval and a housecat) just outside my front door. 

The cat has a blue collar with a bell attached.  No normal cat could stand a chance against him.  Triple check your chicken enclosures and do not leave windows open.  I read in Coastsider someone in

Read more...

Earlier letters

...Looking for something even earlier? Try our letter archives.
Get Coastside alerts from Fire Dispatch on Coastsider's Twitter feed...

A Zen Gift
All About Me Retreats
AM 1710 Neighborhood Radio, Half Moon Bay
Annette Merriman, Alain Pinel Realtors
Center for Personal Growth
Coastside Children’s Programs
Coastside Horse Council
Coastside Net, Half Moon Bay
Coastside Pediatrics, Half Moon Bay
Coastside Stuff, T-shirts & apparel, Half Moon Bay
COGL Communications, El Granada
Colquhoun Glass Works, El Granada
Custom Cabinet Refacing, Half Moon Bay
Darin Boville, Montara
Del Mar Properties
EJ Services, Espresso Machine Repair, Pacifica
Ellen Silva Creative Services, El Granada
Gruber Construction
Harbor Vista, vacation home, Half Moon bay
HMB Library, Half Moon Bay
KCD Construction, Half Moon Bay
Marian Bennett, Coldwell Banker, Half Moon Bay
Michael & Kathy Rain, Coastal Real Estate, Montara
Montara Beach Coalition
Montara Dog Blog
Montara.com, Montara
Moonside Bakery and Cafe, Half Moon
Next Step English, Half Moon Bay
Pacifica Gardens, Pacifica
Pacifica Riptide, Pacifica
Patricia McKowen Consulting, Half Moon Bay
Pillar Ridge Manufactured Home Community, Moss Beach
Pragmatos
Pt. Montara Lighthouse Hostel, Montara
Regan Daniels, Photographer
Robertson, Bell & Fisher, Coldwell Banker, Half Moon Bay
Rubber Nation Crafts, Half Moon Bay
San Gregorio Store, San Gregorio
San Mateo - SF Counties Cooperative Extension
San Mateo County Resource Conservation District
Spring Mountain Gallery, Half Moon Bay
Sustainable San Mateo County
The Coast Road
Weddings by the Sea, Half Moon Bay
Wendy Pine Florals, Floral Design, Half Moon Bay
Wild Bay Area Photography

Get your website listed here....