Lawsuit challenges habitat protection for snowy plover, 47 other California species
California State Parks
|
The conservative Pacific Legal Foudation has launched a lawsuit challenging the critical habitat designations for 48 listed species of California plants and animals, according to the Mercury News. One species native to coastside, the Western Snowy Plover, is on the list [PDF].
The PLF says the suit builds on a victory that invalidated the designation of thousands of acres of land as critical habitat for the Alameda whipsnake. The PLF argues that critical habitat designations throughout California violate the ESA because the federal agencies did not adequately identify the areas that are essential to species conservation and routinely relied on inadequate economic analyses in evaluating the social impact of designations as required under the act.
The press release quotes PLF attorney Reed Hopper, whose name sounds like that of an endangered species, as saying "This lawsuit will promote species recovery by forcing the federal government to set goals and meet clear standards in designating critical habitat. It’s a win-win for everyone."
The Merc quotes Kieran Suckling, of the Center for Biological Diversity, which has appealed the whipsnake case, as saying "Only the Pacific Legal Foundation is cynical enough to argue that taking away habitat protection will help endangered species."
The lawsuit is on behalf of the Home Builders Association of Northern California, the Building Industry Legal Defense Foundation, the California Chamber of Commerce, the California State Grange, and the Greenhorn Grange.