Boys and Girls Club bulldozes probable wetlands on city’s land without a permit
The Boys and Girls Club of the Coastside has used a bulldozer to grade approximately two acres that it leases from the city of Half Moon Bay. The land that was graded is likely to have included wetlands, and the grading was done without the necessary permits.
"We’ve commenced an investigation," says City Manager Debra Auker. "It appears that work was done without any permits." The city called Boys and Girls Club president David Cline on Friday and told him to stop work on the site. Auker is reviewing city staff’s conversations with Cline as well as the terms of the city’s lease agreement with the organization.
"I talked with David Cline about the site a couple of months ago," Paul Nagengast, the city’s Director of Public Works, told Coastsider. "He asked about grading and I told him they needed a Coastal Development Permit." A CDP would have required a biological assessment of the site. The land is very likely to have contained wetlands, especially on its eastern end, which would have been discovered in the permit process.
Nagengast wanted to emphasize the importance of the permitting process. "The process is not there to hurt people, but to make sure that things like this don’t happen. If there is a permit request, there will be a biological assessment and a review of any existing documentation." He noted that the city should have existing environmental reviews of the site from earlier plans for either a park or a corporation yard on the site.
The group leases the land from the city for a token payment as the proposed site of its long-sought headquarters on the Coastside [HMB Review]. The site, on the south side of Sewer Plant Road, is part of a 14-acre parcel acquired by the city as the future site of a city park. The presence of wetlands was one of the issues that kept the park from being built.
The grading probably took place on Friday. The land is now flat and dry and has a sign on it saying that it is the future of site of the Boys and Girls Club Pumpkin Patch. When we revisited the site on Sunday, the bulldozer was gone, and the following notice was posted on small 8 1/2 by 11 inch signs on stakes in the ground.
STOP
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF VERBAL
REQUEST TO STOP ANY ADDITIONAL
WORK OVER THE WEEKEND ON
BOYS AND GIRLS CLUB [u]PUMPKIN[/u]
[u]PATCH[/u]
DAVID CLINE -
BOYS AND GIRLS CLUB OF THE
COASTSIDE
RECEIVED FROM VOICEMESSAGE
HALF MOON BAY CITY STAFF
AS OF 6-16-05
6:19PM
We held this story, hoping to speak to David Cline, but he has not returned our calls to his voice mail.
The Boys and Girls Club leased the site in 1997 with the goal of building its headquarters there, but abandoned the site in favor of space at the proposed Wavecrest development. The co-location of the Boys and Girls Club was considered a selling point for putting the Coastside’s new middle school at Wavecrest. The combination was considered a selling point for the development. Wavecrest was found to contain endangered species habitat, and the development is now tied up with federal agencies. The school district finally decided that it would be cheaper and faster to renovate Cunha than to continue with its plan to build at Wavecrest.
The Boys and Girls Club has recently told the city it is again interested in building on the site it leases from the city.
Click the link below to see more photos from the site, including the acknowledgement notice from the Boys and Girls Club.